Our client approached us as she had received a letter of claim from the insurance company of her neighbour alleging that a tree in her ownership had caused damage to their property.
Our client notified her insurance company about this letter but her insurers refused to indemnify her in relation to this claim as they said that she had not carried out the steps which had been requested of her to mitigate the claimant’s loss by carrying out work to reduce her tree. Points raised by the insurance company demonstrated an incomplete understanding of how tree root subsidence damage occurs and also assumed the Claimant’s position on causation and mitigation was correct.
We represented the client in the complaints procedure to the insurance company who, following the points on subsidence and mitigation being set out clearly in relation to the facts to his claim, accepted their cover and confirmed that an indemnity would be provided.

