We were instructed by a local authority insurer following a dispute concerning alleged damage to a homeowner’s retaining wall, patio and swimming pool area. The homeowners claimed that three self-seeded trees growing within a highway verge behind their property were responsible for significant structural movement and sought both compensation and the removal of the trees. After initially denying liability, the council later accepted responsibility for the ownership of the trees but continued to dispute whether they were the cause of the damage. Matters escalated when solicitors acting for the homeowners served a pre-action letter supported by a structural engineer’s report, alleging that the trees were causing an ongoing private nuisance and threatening injunction proceedings unless the trees were removed.
Tree Law reviewed the available evidence and advised that the engineering report did not sufficiently establish causation, noting that it relied largely on visual observations and did not include intrusive investigations, root exposure, soil analysis or other testing capable of ruling out alternative explanations for the wall’s failure. We assisted the council in formulating a robust response to the claim, addressing issues of liability, foreseeability and evidential shortcomings while maintaining a constructive approach to engagement.
The council adopted our advice and responded to the claimants, whilst also referring the matter to its arboricultural team for consideration of any appropriate tree management measures. No further evidence or proceedings were forthcoming from the claimants’ solicitors, allowing the matter to conclude without litigation and avoiding the need for costly expert investigations at that stage.

